Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label justice. Show all posts

Sunday, May 7, 2017

Stop demanding forgiveness and do the damn work!


In the aftermath of the recent brutal killing of yet another Black youngster, people of color have, once again, been asked to eschew violence, omit calls for a full investigation leading to the arrest and conviction of the killer police officer, and leap directly to forgiveness.

As I discussed in Columbusing Blackness, “the colonizer mindset (or ytppul ytppuling) is Whiteness moving in the world in the way it best knows how: taking the path of least resistance, typically right through someone else's most sacred of spaces, directly to its destination.” In this particular instance, the destination is the holy space of forgiveness and the path lies directly through the heart of Black America’s grief. Further evidence of ytppul ytppuling; colonizer mindset hard at work.

Why would anyone make such a demand? Emotional survival and avoidance of the pain of their wrong-doing methinks.

Who would have the temerity to make such a demand? Why, the White colonizer of course, accustomed as he/she is to not ever having to actually be contrite for acts committed against others. (cf: the entirety of European colonizer history)

The demand for forgiveness is incredibly odious but what makes it worse is the justification; apparently, Ytppul are making this demand for my benefit! I am reliably informed by good White people that my willingness to forgive White violence and oppression without any evidence of White remorse or contrition is all for my own good! Me. Not guilty White America. No indeed! Those demanding my forgiveness are trying to help me, because I’m too [insert appropriate intellectual or emotional flaw here] to handle the horrors of processing White crimes against Black people. So thoughtful, really. [Gaslighting Level: Expert.]

When you put it that way, how could I possibly refuse? Quite easily, as it turns out.

I certainly appreciate that forgiveness helps me. I get that. I even agree with it. What I do not agree with is any suggestion that I owe anyone my forgiveness on some timeline that works for them. That’s not how this works. Forgiveness is an inside job, worked out according to a timeline determined by the forgiver not the forgivee. External pressure – whether social or emotional – is wholly inappropriate bullshit.

For every NWCL/G (nice White Christian lady or gentleman) who demands that POC forgive yet another murdering police officer I have these few questions:

First, were the late Jordan Edwards a blond, blue-eyed girl, would you demand forgiveness of her friends, her family, and her community before you demanded accountability of the police and a complete explanation of how this dreadful outcome came to be? This is not a rhetorical question.  None of these are.  So, would you?

Second, were the late Jordan Edwards an F student and a general pain-in-the-ass White child, would you say his life should be forfeit before you demanded accountability of the police? A simple "yes" or "no" will suffice.

Third, were the late Jordan Edwards a grown White man with two families and multiple children, a general lay about and drain on the taxpayer, would you say, "Let's wait until we have all the details!" before you demanded accountability of the police? I'll wait.

In any instance where accountability is secondary to the psychic comfort of the perpetrators’ group, privilege is at play, and needs to be called what it is - self-serving bull.....When another Black child has been murdered by the police, and White police at that, White comfort is not the goal of Black forgiveness. Well, to be clear, it’s not the goal for us. Though it obviously is for you. Even as we face the brutal death of one of our children at the hands of your police, in your view your feelings are still the most important thing. Why is that do you think?  

Indeed, if you really gave a crap about the humanity of those who are repeatedly harmed by colonizer Whiteness, you would lean all the way in to the discomfort of my unforgiveness. It might actually change you. But the truth is you have no interest – either real or feigned – in changing yourself. Rather, you want me to change – to contort myself emotionally and spiritually for your comfort. I am resolute however; your comfort is not my concern.

Your adjurations that I forgive may be couched in Biblical terms, but I see them for what they are: a salve to your conscience and an avoidance of the discomfort that the ugliness of racism brings you. You fear a retaliatory response. Welp, you could do something about that couldn’t you? You could learn and behave differently but nope, instead, you demand my silence and my complicity with your violence.

It is the ultimate exercise of White privilege to claim the right to decide who has to forgive and who must be forgiven and worse still, to establish the timeline for same and I am loudly going to call that rubbish out.

Don’t bother to clutch your pearls, reach for your emotional fragility, and wail, "I didn't mean it the way it sounded!". Yeah, you did. You just didn’t think I’d call you on it. Assuming that overly generous Black people will let you off the hook will not work here. Some few may forgive on demand, but many of us are onto your shit now. Many will refuse to allow you ease this time or the next.

Y’all need to sit and stew in your ugliness for a while. Y’all need to worry about backlash, rage and riots. Y’all need to have a come to Black Jesus moment. Y’all need to suffer the torments of the damned and then you need a real repentance moment, not some performative contrition nonsense of the “I’m sorry if anybody was offended” variety.  Nuh uh. The real thing is required.  

Until ‘you people’ are required to experience consequences of your vileness there will be no change in that behavior. The too-quick forgiveness that you invariably demand virtually ensures the behavior will be repeated. If folk walk around feeling like, “Hey, no harm no foul right?!”, “I didn’t mean nothin’ by it!” what impetus is there to do or be better next time around? None.

In the Caribbean, children who suck their fingers are discouraged from so doing so through the liberal application of raw aloe on the offending fingers. Aloe tastes vile and so children learn real quick to stop sticking those fingers in their mouths. America needs some raw aloe.

Don’t demand my forgiveness. Ain’t no Biblical basis for such a demand. Put some aloe on yuh damn fingers and stick them in your mouth. Deal with the bitter taste. Recognize the vileness of your skin kin’s actions. Learn. Grow. We’ll get to forgiveness eventually, maybe right around the time you get around to treating POC like they are equal human beings to your good selves. Here’s an idea: we gon’ follow you there. Lead the way! We will be right behind you.


Sunday, October 16, 2016

A New Notoriety?


An open letter to the no-longer-quite-so-notorious RBG

Dear Justice Ginsburg:

My disappointment couldn't be greater. I thought you were a champion of my rights, but I see now that perhaps I gave you more credit than you deserved. When you suggested (who am I kidding, you did not merely 'suggest', you were pretty clear) that the protest of Kaepernick and others in support of Black life was dumb and disrespectful, I found myself utterly disappointed.

I appreciate every opinion you have written and the overall effect of your work on the bench, but I have to say that your referring to Colin Kaepernick's protest as arrogant and stupid really shook me for a moment. Fortunately, my distress was only momentary.

I keep finding myself having to re-learn that in this society the label liberal doesn't necessarily translate to passionately committed to equality. The great epiphany your utterances forced upon me is this: equality for you is a matter of law whereas for me, it is a matter of existence.

There is no part of my existence that isn't challenged by continuing efforts to erode the notion - at this point it really is only a notion - of equality in these United States. My economic life? Shaped by others' willingness to accept the idea of equality. My professional life? Shaped by others' willingness to accept the idea of equality. My access to health care, education, environmental justice? All, shaped by others' willingness to accept the idea of equality. Reading most of our country's history, as I know you have, one cannot but acknowledge that the journey to equality has long been a helluva challenge for the majority. Pick an era when people of color made the tiniest step forward, then take a look at the era subsequent, and the effort to erase or reverse that step is certain to be found. The truth is out there.


It is in this that we differ.  For you it seems 'equality' is this thing you talk about Monday to Friday, from nine o'clock in the am until five o'clock pm. For me, equality is the journey of every one of the 86,400 seconds of every blessed day. There is no moment when my 'equality' or my 'freedom' can be readily accessed without the possibility of challenge. This is why Kaep kneels.

While you are free to dismiss (and then return a few days later chastened) the protests born of Black folks' reality, that is a privilege to which I do not have access. While you are free to not even know what the protest is about and yet, ignorant of the details, know with an alarming degree of certainty that it is dismissible, that is a privilege I do not have. This is why Kaep kneels. 

You are, of course, absolutely entitled to your opinion on Kaepernick, just as I am entitled to my opinion of your opinion. That's what freedom is.

However, freedom begins to end, and something else begins, when your opinion coupled with your relative power, has the capacity to negatively impact my access to basic safety. When your opinion + your power have the capacity to ennoble the unlawful (and often deadly) actions of police officers, vigilantes, right wing zealots, and various internet trolls against people like me. That is not freedom. Well, to be certain, in that situation, you continue to enjoy freedom, but it is a version of freedom that undermines and negates mine. 

Herein lies another thing that differentiates between us.

For you, the SCOTUS serves to solidify the law; to establish clear, hard lines that must not be crossed. Yet, don't those lines get crossed anyway? Don't people get executed who shouldn't? Don’t people spend decades in jail who oughtn’t? Don't bad things happen to good people (and sometimes to bad ones as well)?

In your SCOTUS-world, justice requires that I first be harmed. That is justice to you. It ain’t no justice to me, however. I’m not surprised that you’re OK with this version of American justice though, since you’re not the one being shot at, brutalized, or worse, killed.

We would prefer not to be harmed at all. This is why Kaep kneels.

We would prefer a system that seeks to prevent our injury, rather than one that offers a Band-Aid for our bullet wounds. Your comfort with reactive justice works for you because that is the privilege that your position and race afford you. My commitment though, must be to pre-emptive justice; proactive justice; justice at the initial point of contact with the system, rather than at the end. 

After 400 years of America’s reactive approach to ‘justice’, people of color have cottoned on to the fact that the time for a proactively just system is now. This is why Kaep kneels.  This is why others now join him: because there is no effective redress for the fatal harms the system so giddily metes out.

It matters not what your opinion is on the case of Tamir Rice, John Crawford III, Rekia Boyd, Aiyana Stanley-Jones, Philando Castile, Alton Sterling, Jeremy Mardis, or the hundreds of other men, women, and children slaughtered by police, because they’ve all gone to glory, and there is still no treatment for that. There’s no assessment you and your sister and brother justices can offer that will bring redress. And so we kneel.

It matters not the results of your ex post facto review of the case of X or Y prisoner held on Death Row for a crime he/she did not commit. Those days, weeks, months, years are lost. Forever. We seek justice first. We seek a system wherein equality is the basis, the starting point, not a result insisted upon by a judge and which – like the SCOTUS school desegregation order of 1954 – can be flouted by the powerful.

The courts' eventual adjudication of innocence for the dead or the falsely accused/incarcerated serves no purpose other than to give the system and those who hold privilege within it a reason to feel good; such adjudication is but an opportunity for the society to pretend it is evolving. The reality is that those who were harmed in the first place remain eternally harmed.

This form of redress is a Pyrrhic victory of the meanest sort. SCOTUS justice, with all due respect, is a Sponge Bob Square Pants Band-Aid on a gaping, festering sore. The financial, social and emotional consequences of having been fatally wronged can never be fixed. There can be no ‘justice’ after the fact. This is why Kaepernick kneels.

It would have cost you nothing but the discomfort of shrugging off your privilege, to acknowledge any of these truths. Thank you for showing me that even that shrug is a bridge too far.

Until now, I have presumed that your decisions meant that you actually cared about the people about whom you were deciding. Your recent interview tells me that that was a mistaken assumption on my part. My bad. I won't do it again. 

Regards,
Me